Wednesday 22 July 2009

On Speedboats, Albania’s Sex Trade Could Flare

On Speedboats, Albania’s Sex Trade Could Flare

Matt Lutton for The New York Times

An abandoned fishing boat on a beach in Vlore, Albania, a city known for being a hub for human trafficking across Europe.

Published: July 16, 2009

VLORE, Albania — It was only after her trafficker sealed her mouth with electrical tape, drugged her and threatened to kill her family that the childlike woman, now 27, says she realized that the man she had planned to marry had seduced her with a terrible lie.

Skip to next paragraph

Related

Times Topics: Sexual Slavery

Her journey at age 18 from an Albanian village to a London brothel, where she said she spent five years working as a prostitute, began with a gold engagement ring, the promise of a better life abroad and — like many before her — a speedboat trip to Italy under the cover of night.

So many women, men and children had been trafficked abroad to work as prostitutes, forced laborers or beggars that the Albanian government three years ago barred all Albanian citizens from using speedboats, the favored transportation used by traffickers to get people out of the country.

This drastic measure, coupled with stricter border controls and revenge killings of traffickers by victims’ families, had a significant effect, reducing trafficking by more than half and all but ending Albania’s role as a major transit point for people trafficked to Western Europe from eastern and southern parts of the Continent, say experts who follow trafficking.

But the ban prompted loud protests from fishermen and people in the tourism industry, and in May it was reversed. Law enforcement and human rights officials are concerned that as a result, human trafficking may explode anew — at an especially difficult time.

The financial crisis, many experts said, could increase human trafficking around the world. A United States State Department report in June warned of the potential risk, saying that the crisis is causing “a shrinking demand for labor and a growing supply of workers willing to take ever greater risks for economic opportunities.”

In the case of Albania, a poor, southern Balkan country that joined NATO in April and seeks to join the European Union, the government’s ability to fight trafficking is viewed as a critical test.

For victims like the woman from the small village, ensnared by the false promises of her trafficker, that fight is a matter of survival.

“I was in love with him, I dreamed of living my life with him, but it was all a big lie,” she said in a recent interview at a shelter for trafficking victims. “I wanted to run away, but in the eyes of the law, I was a prostitute with fake documents. Where was I to go?”

She said the man who abducted her had gained her trust over months, then locked her in a room and took her passport and cellphone. She said he beat her and cut her with a penknife, a warning of what he would do if she tried to escape. She said she was forced to be a prostitute in London and in Antwerp, Belgium. To cover their tracks, the man’s family had called her parents and said that the couple had moved to neighboring Kosovo.

The woman would not provide her name for fear of retribution from the trafficker, making it impossible to corroborate her story with the police report she said she had filed against the man. But the coordinator and director of the shelter where she is staying have reviewed the details of her case and vouched for her credibility.

At the height of the trafficking, experts estimate, thousands of women, men and children were taken to nearby Greece and Italy and elsewhere for sexual exploitation or forced labor.

The United Nations estimates that 12.3 million people globally are employed in sexual servitude or forced labor. Many are lured by fake engagements, real marriages or false job offers. In some cases, victims have been sold by their families. Others go voluntarily.

Even with the speedboat ban last year, the State Department said in its June report that in 2008, Albania did not comply with “the minimum standards for the elimination of trafficking,” although it made “significant efforts to do so.” The report said corruption remained pervasive.

In June 2007, the Ministry of Interior arrested 12 police officers accused of human trafficking in three cases, including six officers with direct responsibility for anti-trafficking enforcement.

Albanian law enforcement officials say that help from other countries in getting evidence to convict traffickers is often lacking. Iva Zajmi, the anti-trafficking coordinator at the Ministry of Interior, stressed that as a result of legal or tolerated prostitution in countries like Belgium, Germany and the Netherlands, many trafficked women were not identified as victims in those countries.

“The legalization of prostitution has created a wall behind which traffickers can hide and repress victims,” she said.

Trafficking took root in Albania in 1991, in the aftermath of the fall of Communism, and for nearly 10 years, traffickers worked with impunity in the absence of trafficking laws. The problem peaked in 1997 as a financial pyramid scheme shook Albania and pushed the country to the brink of civil war.

“Albanians were selling their sisters for money,” said Ilir Yzeiri, an Albanian writer who made a documentary on human trafficking.

In 2004, the government created courts to try trafficking cases and passed tough trafficking laws, including prison sentences of up to 15 years for traffickers.

  • 1
  • 2

Monday 6 July 2009

Ergenekon Case- A Typicial Scheme of State Capture by Organised Crime

Deep state' trial polarises Turkey

By Sarah Rainsford
BBC News, Istanbul

Ergenekon supporters rally in Istanbul. Photo: 20 October 2008
Nationalists see the Ergenekon trial as a travesty of justice
The so-called Ergenekon case is huge, both in the size of the prosecutor's indictment and its political significance.

Even excluding its many appendices, the indictment is a massive 2,455 pages-long.

It describes an incredible-sounding plot linking lawyers, academics, a mafia man, a hitman and former members of the military, in an alleged ultra-nationalist conspiracy to topple Turkey's Islamist-rooted government.

In all, 86 suspects are now on trial, facing charges ranging from possession of firearms to running an armed terrorist organisation.

The first clue to this shadowy network was discovered last summer in the small pink house of a former military officer, next door to an Istanbul fish restaurant. Inside was a cache of hand grenades and explosives.

I believe there are so many connections with the army. We want to discover all of them with this trial
Oral Calislar
Turkey's Radikal newspaper

"The Ergenekon terror organisation is known as the 'deep state' in our country and organises many bloody activities aiming to create an atmosphere of serious crisis, chaos, anarchy and terror," writes prosecutor Zekeriya Oz, in an indictment drawn-up after months of police investigation, raids and extensive phone-taps.

Its purpose, he says, is "to weaken the country's administration [and] justify an illegal intervention against the government."

Polarising case

The prosecutor links Ergenekon to the murder of a secularist judge in 2006 and a grenade attack on the Istanbul office of Cumhuriyet newspaper, a publication known for its opposition to the religious-minded government.

I think this government is using the case to establish a dictatorship in Turkey
Leyla Tavsanoglu
Cumhuriyet newspaper

Previously ascribed to an Islamic fundamentalist, the attacks are now described as the first stage of Ergenekon's campaign to stoke divisions and unrest.

The indictment also cites an alleged hit-list, including Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan and Nobel prize-winning writer Orhan Pamuk as targets.

Such details have excited intense interest in Turkey, but the case is dividing public opinion.

To some, it is a clear travesty of justice.

Earlier this year the prime minister's religious conservative governing party, the AK Party, was tried and acquitted of trying to Islamise Turkey - which was founded as a strictly secular state. Critics now accuse the party of taking revenge on its opponents, including the military.

One of the defendants arrives at the courtroom for the trial. Photo: 20 October 2008
Secularist academics like Kemal Alemdaroglu are among the accused

"I think this government is using the case to establish a dictatorship in Turkey," says Leyla Tavsanoglu, a columnist for Cumhuriyet. Her newspaper's elderly editor - a staunch secularist - has been arrested in a dawn police-raid on his house.

"Now everyone is subdued. They have clamped down on the democratic opposition and everyone is afraid that one day they will be included in another wave of arrests," Ms Tavsanoglu explains.

Some have stopped using mobile phones just in case.

'Deep state'

To others though, the Ergenekon trial is a watershed in Turkey's democratisation.

There is demand for democracy inside Turkey now... So those [old forces] are going to lose in the end
Can Paker
Tesev think-tank

Two retired generals have been charged in connection with the case, although their indictment has not been released yet.

Their arrest is unprecedented in a country that has seen four military coups and whose generals have long been a powerful political force.

One of the central pieces of evidence in the case, a document entitled "Lobi", describes Ergenekon as operating "under the Turkish armed forces".

In his indictment, the prosecutor records having sent an official inquiry about that to the army's general staff, and to and Turkish intelligence - both denied the link.

But liberal commentators say the prosecutor has a duty to use this trial for a thorough investigation of the claim, to root-out any rogue elements within Turkey's security forces.

"In Europe, these 'Gladios' or counter-guerrilla organisations were discovered and removed from the state and the army. In Turkey, we never confronted them and what they were doing," says Oral Calislar, a writer for Radikal liberal newspaper.

Many Turks talk darkly of a "deep state" - groups they suspect of links to the security forces since the 1950s, formed to carry out illegal activities, including assassinations, to "protect" the republic.

Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan in parliament, 15 July 08
PM Recep Tayyip Erdogan insists he does not have an Islamist agenda

Their alleged crimes include the murder of many prominent writers and intellectuals and the disappearance and killing of many Kurds during the Kurdish conflict in the 1990s.

First confirmation of those suspicions came in 1996, when the passengers in a fatal car crash in Susurluk revealed clear links between state security officers, organised criminals and politicians.

It emerged that a senior police chief, a prominent MP and a wanted assassin were travelling in the car together. The assassin - a nationalist militant - was carrying government-backed diplomatic ID.

The main perceived threat to the state at that time was Kurdish separatism. Earlier, communism was the danger. Today, it is political Islam and the AK Party.

'Demand for democracy'

So much of the buzz surrounding the Ergenekon trial is over whether Turkey's "deep state" will finally be exposed and eradicated.

"I believe there are so many connections with the army. We want to discover all of them with this trial," says Mr Calislar. "We will fight for that because we want to live in a democratic society."

Turkey's democratic transition is what Can Paker believes this case is all about.

The head of the liberal Tesev think-tank describes a power struggle between Turkey's old elite - the civil and military bureaucracy - and a rising urban middle-class. He sees the threat of political Islam as a weapon in the struggle against the AKP and its electorate and suggests Ergenekon emerged from that.

"I believe parts of the military and civil bureaucracy co-operate with them, so that their common benefits will not be disturbed," Mr Paker explains.

"These groups are all against [Turkey joining] the EU because they will lose power, because it will mean more democracy, more individual rights, more transparency. They are prepared to use force and intrigue and any kind of provocative action," he says.

Sceptics maintain serious doubts about the motive and the focus of the prosecutor's Ergenekon enquiry.

Many also doubt it will dig too deep.

But supporters argue the fact the trial is even happening shows how much society has changed.

"There is demand for democracy inside Turkey now, and from outside," Mr Paker explains. "So those [old forces] are going to lose in the end. But at what pace - I don't know."

Freedom House: Nations in Transit 2009

Freedom House’s Annual Survey Nations in Transit (NIT) tracks democratic developments and setbacks of 29 countries in the former Communist states of Europe and Eurasia. The 2009 report observes a worrying regional trend with more than half of the countries backsliding in democratic reforms, or continuing on a dangerous trajectory towards authoritarian governance. Being released shortly before the US-Russian Summit, Nations in Transit serves as a reminder to keep democracy issues high on the agenda in the West’s relations with Russia and its neighbors.

Table of Contents

2009 Summary

Nations in Transit 2009 is the 13th edition of Freedom House’s comprehensive, comparative study of democratic development from Central Europe to Eurasia. It examines 29 countries, including the newest independent state in the region, Kosovo. The overarching conclusion is that 2008 was a very difficult year for democracy: scores declined for 18 of the 29 countries, and a record 8 countries are now in the “consolidated authoritarian regimes” category.Worrying trends highlighted in the previous three editions of Nations in Transit became even more pronounced in 2008, while positive trends lost momentum. A number of events illustrate the intensification of these negative trends.

In 2008, for the first time in the 21st century, a war erupted between two states covered in Nations in Transit. The so-called “August War” between Georgia and Russia served as a wake-up call for those who believed that the democratic decline observed in the region over the last few years would not have a detrimental effect on security and stability. Highly problematic elections accentuated the region’s troubles. Two petro-states, Azerbaijan (which recorded the largest democratic decline in this edition of Nations in Transit) and the Russian Federation, held uncompetitive presidential elections in which the result was predetermined. Armenia’s presidentialpoll was marred by lethal postelection violence. And the government in Georgia used administrative resources to seriously influence that country’s hotly contestedpresidential and parliamentary elections. Nations in Transit 2009 documents how journalists were once again at risk throughout the region, from Croatia to Uzbekistan, and national governments were challenged by corruption scandals, as was the case in Bulgaria; by divisive ethnic politics, as in Bosnia and Herzegovina; by parliamentary boycotts, as in Montenegro; or by infighting and outright irresponsibility among political leaders, as in Ukraine.

On June 30, Freedom House is releasing all 29 country summaries from the 2009 Edition of Nations in Transit, along with full reports for Russia, The Czech Republic, and Uzbekistan. The remaining country reports will be available online shortly. If you would like to be notified when all reports are available for downloading, please register with your email address here This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it .

A chronology of key events in Albania

Timeline: Albania

A chronology of key events:

1939 - Shortly before the start of World War II, Italy invades. King Zog flees to Greece.

ENVER HOXHA
Supporters of late Communist leader Enver Hoxha at his grave, 2003
Some still revere Communist leader who ruled with iron fist
Born in 1908
1944: Became prime minister
Died in 1985

1940 - Italian army attacks Greece through Albania.

1941 - Enver Hoxha becomes head of new Albanian Communist Party.

1943 - German forces invade and occupy Albania following Italian surrender.

1944 - Germans withdraw after Communist resistance. Enver Hoxha installed as new leader.

1945 - Tribunals begin against thousands of "war criminals".

1946 - Purges of non-communists from government positions.

1948 - Albania breaks ties with Yugoslavia; Soviet Union begins economic aid to Albania.

1950 - Britain and US back landings by right-wing guerillas, who fail to topple communists.

1955 - Albania becomes a founding member of the Warsaw Pact.

Isolationist state

1961 - Albania allies itself with China, after Soviet Union breaks diplomatic relations over ideological rift.

TIRANA
Tirana skyline
Capital city became a magnet for incomers in the 1990s
Founded in 17th century
Became capital in 1920
Population: 353,000 (official estimate)

1967 - Violent clampdown on religious activity. Albania declared the world's first atheist state.

1968 - Albania withdraws from Warsaw Pact over Soviet-led invasion of Czechoslovakia.

1978 - China ends economic and military aid to Albania after relations become strained by China's reconciliation with the US.

1985 - Hoxha dies, replaced by Ramiz Alia.

Political upheavals

1989 - Communist rule in Eastern Europe collapses. Ramiz Alia signals changes to economic system.

1990 - Independent political parties formed. Albanians granted right to travel abroad. Thousands try to flee through Western embassies.

Thousands more seize ships at port and sail illegally to Italy.

1991 - In multiparty elections, the Communist Party and allies win 169 of the 250 seats, the newly-formed Democratic Party takes 75.

General amnesty for political prisoners. First opposition newspaper published.

Alia re-elected president. Prime Minister Fatos Nano resigns after protests at economic conditions and killing of opposition demonstrators.

New government headed by Vilson Ahmeti.

1992 - Democratic Party wins elections. Party leader Sali Berisha, a former cardiologist, becomes first elected president. Aleksander Meksi is prime minister.

1993 - Ex-communist leaders, including Fatos Nano and Ramiz Alia, convicted and jailed for corruption.

Anger on streets

1994 - National referendum rejects new constitution which opponents said allowed president too much power.

1995 - Alia released from prison following appeal-court ruling.

1996 - Democratic Party general election victory tainted by accusations of fraud.

1997 - Leka, son of late King Zog, returns from exile in bid to take throne. Referendum on restoration of monarchy fails. He is accused of trying to stir up an armed insurrection and flees back into exile.

KOSOVO CRISIS
Refugees from Kosovo cross into Albania during 1998 conflict
Kosovo Albanian refugees poured across the border into Albania

Fraudulent pyramid investment schemes collapse, costing thousands of Albanians their savings and triggering anti-government protests.

Up to a million weapons are looted from army stores as angry mobs take to the streets.

Government resigns and Socialist-led coalition sweeps to power. Fatos Nano, now released from prison, returns as prime minister.

Sali Berisha resigns as president in wake of financial crisis, succeeded by Socialist leader Rexhep Mejdani.

Convictions of communist-era leaders overturned.

1998 - Escalating unrest in Kosovo sends refugees across border into Albania.

September - Violent anti-government street protests after prominent opposition Democratic Party politician, Azem Hajdari, shot dead by unidentified gunmen.

PM Fatos Nano quits. Former student activist, Pandeli Majko, named as new prime minister.

Refugee influx

1999 - Nato air strikes against Yugoslav military targets. In Kosovo thousands flee attacks by Serb forces. Mass refugee exodus into Albania.

October - Majko resigns as prime minister in October 1999, after losing Socialist Party leadership vote. 30-year-old Iler Meta becomes Europe's youngest prime minister.

2001 January - Albania and Yugoslavia re-establish diplomatic relations broken off during the Kosovo crisis in 1999.

LEKA ZOG
Leka, son of ex-king Zog
Son of former king fled in 1997, returned after 2002 amnesty

2001 April - UN says thousands of Albanians are being poisoned by fatal toxins in their environment, urges international community to help.

2001 July - Ruling Socialist Party secures second term in office by winning general elections. PM Meta names European integration and an end to energy shortages as his priorities. Meta heads a new coalition government from September.

2001 December - Rift widens between Meta and his Socialist Party Chairman Fatos Nano. Nano prompts three ministers to resign and blocks the appointment of their replacements.

2002 January - Meta resigns as prime minister after failing to resolve party feud.

2002 February - Pandeli Majko becomes premier and forms new government as rival factions in Socialist Party pledge to end infighting.

2002 June - Parliament elects Alfred Moisiu president after rival political leaders Nano and Berisha reach compromise, easing months of tension.

Royal family returns from exile.

Port, Durres, Albania (2004 picture)
Founded by the ancient Greeks, Durres is Albania's main port

2002 August - Fatos Nano becomes prime minister after the ruling Socialist Party decides to merge the roles of premier and party chairman. It is Nano's fourth time as premier.

2003 January - Albania and EU begin Stabilisation and Association Agreement talks, seen as possible first step in long road to EU membership.

2004 January - Day of mourning declared after at least 20 people die when the boat on which they were trying to cross to Italy illegally breaks down in mid-Adriatic.

2004 February - Opposition stages angry demonstration in Tirana to demand Mr Nano's resignation and protest against government failure to improve living standards.

2005 September - After two months of political wrangling, former president Sali Berisha emerges as the victor in July's general election.

2006 April - Parliament imposes ban on speedboats in coastal waters in bid to crackdown on people and drug smuggling.

2006 June - Stabilisation and Association agreement signed with EU.

2007 June - President George W Bush becomes the first US leader to visit Albania, highlighting its position as a close ally of Washington.

2007 July - Parliament elects ruling party chairman Bamir Topi president, after three failed rounds of voting made a snap election look possible.

2008 March - Defence Minister Fatmir Mediu resigns over arms depot blasts that killed 16 and damaged Tirana airport.

2009 April - Albania officially joins NATO and formally applies for membership of the European Union. Albania is not expected to join the EU until 2015 at the earliest.

2009 June - Albanians go to the polls in parliamentary elections.